Top 5 Best Mary Jane Pumps 2017

Perhaps, pumps are the most famous and favorite shoes among women today. They look great with a business outfit, skirts, jeans and evening dresses. And popular model among pumps is Mary Jane.
Mary Jane pumps are closed shoes with a strap across the instep and rounded toe. Today you can find a huge variety of Mary Jane pumps. They are made of different materials, with different height of heels or without heels at all, with a pointed or rounded toe. If you still do not have any of these in your wardrobe – it’s time to find your perfect pair.
We choose top 5 models and below you can find comparison table, which includes their characteristic and general mark.

Brand Chase & Chloe Journee Collection City Classified Forever Alegria
Model 2017 Kimmy-21 Women’s Round Toe Pierced Mid Heel Mary Jane Style Dress Pumps Womens Mary Jane Faux Leather Pumps Sully’S Kaylee-H Mary-Jane Pumps-Shoes Womens Patricia-05 Mary Jane Strap Faux Suede Wedge Pumps Women’s Coco Mary Jane Pump

Chase & Chloe Kimmy-21 Women's Round Toe Pierced Mid Heel Mary Jane Style Dress Pumps Thumb

Journee Collection Womens Mary Jane Faux Leather Pumps Thumb

City Classified Womens Kaylee-H Mary Jane Pumps Shoes Thumb

Forever Link Womens Patricia-05 Mary Jane Strap Faux Suede Wedge Pumps Thumb

Alegria Women's Coco Mary Jane Pump Thumb
Material Synthetic body/Synthetic sole Faux leather/Synthetic sole Synthetic body/Synthetic sole Synthetic suede/Synthetic sole Leather/Synthetic sole
Colors 8 colors 11 colors 8 colors 3 colors 2 colors
Features Adjustable ankle strap/Stitching details/Vegan Double straps across the vamps/A small chunky heel/Vegan Mid-heel/Round-toe/Vegan Mid-heel/Round-toe/Vegan Removable memory foam/Arch support/Non marking outsole
Mark 7 9 8 6 10

Chase & Chloe Kimmy-21 Women’s Round Toe Pierced Mid Heel Mary Jane Style Dress Pumps

Chase & Chloe Kimmy-21 Women's Round Toe Pierced Mid Heel Mary Jane Style Dress Pumps


  • Synthetic
  • Synthetic sole
  • Platform measures approximately 0.25″ (0.64 cm)
  • Stitching details
  • Heel height measures approximately 3.25″ (8.26 cm)
  • Adjustable ankle strap

These glamorous and elegant Mary Jane pumps with a mid heel and round toe will add a feminine touch to every outfit. They look fun, cute and flirty with any kind of dress or skirt. This model from Chase and Chloe has stitching details and adjustable ankle strap. Shoes are made of synthetic materials and 100% vegan. They are available in 8 bright colors.
However, these Mary Jane pumps have some disadvantages. They have no cushion or support so they can be not very comfortable. A new pair of shoes can have an unpleasant and strong smell and the texture on the bottom is quite slippery.


  • Stylish and fashionable
  • A great variety of bright colors
  • Comfortable small heel
  • Vegan


  • No support
  • Can have strong smell
  • Slippery sole
  • Sizes can be not correct

Journee Collection Womens Mary Jane Faux Leather Pumps

Journee Collection Womens Mary Jane Faux Leather Pumps


  • Material: faux leather/man-made
  • Synthetic sole
  • Heel height: 3.3″ (8.38 cm)
  • Platform height: 0.4″ (1.02 cm)
  • Width: medium and wide widths are available

These classic and practical pumps from Journee Collection feature round toes and double straps across the vamps.
They are available in different classic colors like red, black, gray, nude, beige, white and navy. These pumps are made of faux leather (mat models) and synthetic material (varnished models).
You can choose mat pair for more casual and classic look and a varnished pair will fit perfectly with more glamorous and fashionable outfit.
Small heels are very comfortable, but in some cases, they need a break-in period. Sole of the shoes don’t have much grip so they can be slippery.


  • Good quality
  • Comfy
  • Stylish
  • Colors are very attractive
  • Vegan


  • Slippery sole
  • Size can be not correct

City Classified Womens Kaylee-H Mary Jane Pumps Shoes

City Classified Womens Kaylee-H Mary Jane Pumps Shoes


  • Synthetic
  • Synthetic sole
  • Heel height approximately 2.75″ (6.99 cm)
  • Mid-heel
  • Round-toe
  • Vegan

Vintage-inspired Mary Jane pumps from City Classified can add elegance to any look. They are universal and they are good for every occasion. You can wear these pumps for work, for study, on a date or for a walk. They are designed in 2 different styles: mat and varnished and available in neutral colors like beige and black. These Mary Jane are made of sturdy man-made leather and faux suede, the sole is synthetic too. They don’t contain animal products and completely vegan. Mid heel is comfortable, but pumps don’t have much padding. For narrow feet, these shoes will work great, but in another case, you can have problems during the break-in period. Also, like the other reviewed models, the bottom of this shoe doesn’t have much grip.


  • Stylish and vintage looking pumps
  • Universal, will look good with any outfit
  • Vegan


  • Slippery soles
  • Works great only with narrow feet
  • Don’t have much padding

Forever Link Womens Patricia-05 Mary Jane Strap Faux Suede Wedge Pumps

Forever Link Womens Patricia-05 Mary Jane Strap Faux Suede Wedge Pumps


  • Synthetic sole
  • Synthetic suede
  • Platform measures approximately 0.25″(0.64 cm)
  • Heel Height approximately 2.5″ (6.35 cm)
  • Mid-heel
  • Round-toe
  • Vegan

These Mary Jane Pumps from Forever have a comfortable mid-height platform and round toe, which make them a good choice for every woman, who loves trendy and fashionable shoes. They are made of synthetic suede and available in 3 neutral colors: black, tan and taupe. Unlike the other models, these shoes have rubber non-slippery sole. But unfortunately, bottoms of these pumps are not of a very good quality and can start to come apart after some time of wearing. The material is slightly hard and this model doesn’t have much padding, so it’s recommended to wear them with socks to avoid blisters and rubbing. Also, if you have wide feet we wouldn’t recommend these as they are pretty narrow.


  • Nifty
  • Have comfortable mid-height platform
  • Nonslippery soles
  • Vegan


  • Not of a good quality
  • The material is slightly hard
  • Not recommended for women with wide feet

Alegria Women’s Coco Mary Jane Pump

Alegria Women's Coco Mary Jane Pump


  • Leather
  • Synthetic sole
  • Heel measures approximately 2″ (5.08 cm)
  • Removable memory foam
  • Removable cork footbed
  • Arch support
  • Nonmarking outsole

Alegria brand offers unique design with excellent support and comfort due to removable cork footbed. This beautiful Mary Jane shoe will become your favorite companion and will add the playful vibe to your look. They are lightweight and breathable thanks to its leather lining. It’s a good comfortable shoe with a roomy toe box, featuring a leather upper with a front strap. They also have a hoop-and-loop closure for a precise and adjustable fit.
Removable memory foam provides great comfort and support to your feet during all day. They are available in 2 interesting colors: pewter and safari. But unfortunately, these shoes need a break-in period.


  • Comfortable
  • Breathable
  • Unique style
  • Provides support


  • They can be not true to size

Our Leader

As you can see, our leader is Alegria Women’s Coco Mary Jane Pump. They are made of high-quality leather that provides all-day comfort for your feet. Also, their interesting and remarkable design and colors won’t leave you indifferent. Other models also have high general marks and have more casual look. So, if you are more into some classic design of Mary Jane pumps, other reviewed shoes would be also a great choice.

History of Mary Jane Pumps

Initially, Mary Jane shoes were made with a flat sole for little girls. They got their name “Mary Jane” from the heroine of the comics, who was depicted in shoes with a strap and a rounded toe.
But in the 1940s Mary Jane pumps began to gain its popularity among women. And in the 60s these shoes appeared in the collections of famous designers, who changed their form by adding a heel and a more pointed toe. The peak of popularity of Mary Jane’s shoes was in the 90s.
Till now Mary Jane pumps haven’t lost their popularity because they look great with almost every outfit.
Transformed throughout the ages, Mary Jane pumps prove to be versatile and stylish shoes.

How to choose?

Nowadays in the shops, you can find both classic Mary Jane shoes and all sorts of its variations. You can find these pumps in casual and even sports style.
However, choosing Mary Jane shoes you should remember some rules. Firstly, the strap and the rounded toe will make your foot look begger. If you have wide feet it’s better to avoid horizontal stripes, because they make wide feet even wider. And the last, the strap can visually shorten your legs, so it’s better to choose models that have a heel.
Mary Jane pumps are very versatile so they will work with every type of outfit in your closet whether your style is casual or corporate, feminine or eclectic. They will work with night dresses, jeans, coats, sweaters, casual dresses, skirts, suits and so on. If you are worried that Mary Jane pumps will look childish on you try to find a pair with a heel and a strap that is a little lower on the instep.

Allegra K Women’s Shoe Size Chart

US Size Heel to Toe Heel Height Platform Height
5.5 8 3/4 3 3/4 1 1/4
6 9 3 3/4 1 1/4
7 9 3/8 3 3/4 1 1/4
7.5 9 3/8 3 3/4 1 1/4
8 9 5/8 3 3/4 1 1/4
8.5 9 7/8 3 3/4 1 1/4
9 10 3 3/4 1 1/4
9.5 10 3 3/4 1 1/4
10 10 3/8 3 3/4 1 1/4
  1. Reply
    Angela August 29, 2017 at 10:48 am

    Pumps by Alegria combined convenience and elegance. Perfectly approached even for my problem legs.

  2. Reply
    Ruth September 12, 2017 at 6:42 pm

    Patricia-05 could be on my feet for whole day. Definitely Mary Jane style wins when you wear suits for work and walk a lot. This heels is not only comfortable, but really looks great.

  3. Reply
    Yolanda September 12, 2017 at 11:49 pm

    A few words about Chase & Chloe. Excellent stylish shoes. I bought in a Nude color. Fit well. Good in arch. Slippery sole is only one drawback. In the rest everything is fine.

  4. Reply
    Paula Nunez September 26, 2017 at 6:27 pm

    Alegria is absolutely perfect! I spend a lot of time on feet and these shoes are the most comfortable. My wide feet need special footwear. It’s hard to find something perfect for me. Finally, I bought these model and I’m satisfied. Want to buy one more.

  5. Reply
    Rebecca September 30, 2017 at 3:20 pm

    Journee Collection pumps are not the most comfortable shoes. Look very cool, but they are very hard to wear. The material from which they are made is very coarse and rubs the feet.

Leave a reply